Lessons from Reconstruction


In “The Terror of Reconstruction,” Lew Rockwell highlights the dangers of governments seeking to suppress their political opponents by an assault on citizens’ liberties. He draws upon the experience of the South under military dictatorship during the Reconstruction years as an example of what happens when governments embark on social revolution. One tactic described by Rockwell is denying the vote to those who supported their opponents:

In the Reconstruction era, practically the entire white population was denied the right to vote. The disenfranchisement wasn’t just confined to officials in the former Confederate government. Even those who had given money to help wounded Confederate veterans or who had bought bonds couldn’t vote.

Another tactic, described by Charles Adams in his book Human Events, was to force free black people to vote in favor of the candidate preferred by the government. This seems to have been well known at the time, as Adams gives the example of a German paper with a cartoon titled “In the Polling Booth,” which depicted a black man being forced to vote for the radical republicans. The caption read, “Ballots for Republicans! Bullets For Democrats! Death To Colored Democrats!”

The terror of Reconstruction illustrates the destruction caused by government regulations and interventions which are said to be necessary to bring about social harmony and good race relations. In his treatise The Rise and Fall of the Confederate Government, Jefferson Davis issues “a warning to the people against the dangers by which their liberties are beset.” It is a warning to be vigilant in recognizing and opposing threats to liberty even when—or especially when—such threats emanate from the state. Davis details how the victorious federal government took the opportunity to occupy the South, sending in the army to enforce

…the universal denial of unalienable personal rights, the destruction of civil institutions, the disregard of laws, and the cruel and ignominious treatment, inflicted by the authority of the Government of the United States upon individuals in every part of the Southern country.

Davis shows that by this means, the federal government conferred upon itself the mandate and the power to regulate every aspect of life in the occupied South. For example, emancipation orders declared that “it is the duty of the army to maintain the freedom” of liberated slaves, followed by government orders “defining and regulating the relations of freedmen and whites.” Although not explicitly stated, the implication of such government edicts was that people in the South could not be expected to manage by themselves to live in peace without the federal authorities present to dictate every aspect of their lives.

Far from these interventions keeping the peace, they only sowed the seeds of further discord, which the government then tried to correct with even more regulations and ultimately the suspension of habeas corpus. Adams highlights the resentment and racial hostility fomented by the federal government pitting black against white in the occupied South:

The game plan of the Yankees was to use the ex-slaves to take over Southern society and wealth. It was easy to entice the ex-slaves with promises of glory—that they would soon be masters over the whites if they would only do as they were told. Unfortunately, they did.

Adams observes that, “the conduct of the returning black soldiers in Yankee uniforms…did more to turn Southern whites against all blacks than did the carpetbaggers and conquering armies of occupation.”

This is a tragic example of the upheaval and conflict that arises in the wake of government attempts to bring about social change through race-craft—politicians stoking racial grievances to earn more votes for themselves. It is a timely warning of the potential harm that could result from race-based electioneering, such as Kamala Harris’ plan to “plan to empower Black men as she tries to energize them to vote for her.” She has promised to give “forgivable business loans for Black entrepreneurs” of up to $1 million, and “to ensure that Black men have opportunities to participate as a national cannabis industry takes shape.”

Not only does she promise to legalize drugs, but also to give preferences to black “entrepreneurs” in the cannabis industry. The disastrous outcome of the federal government’s reconstruction plans in the aftermath of the War for Southern Independence should serve as a warning against such cynical attempts to appeal to voters based on their racial identity.

 


Originally Posted at https://mises.org/


  • Related Posts

    What Ceasefire? ‘Heavy Clashes’ In South Lebanon As Beirut Buildings Leveled

    What Ceasefire? ‘Heavy Clashes’ In South Lebanon As Beirut Buildings Leveled

    Despite all the recent talk of a potential ceasefire between Hezbollah and Israel in the works, regional reports say that some of the fiercest ground fighting is currently taking place in southern Lebanon on Friday.

    Heavy Israeli aerial bombardments of the southern suburbs of Beirut have also continued with intensity. On Friday an Israeli missile completely leveled a residential multi-story in the neighborhood of Chiyah. Israel’s military reportedly issued a civilian evacuation alert shortly before, and terrifying video from the scene suggests locals knew it was about to be struck.

    In the south of Lebanon, near the border, UN peacekeeping forces say they are monitoring “heavy clashes” on Friday, saying most of the fighting is centered in the coastal town of Naqoura as well as the village of Chamaa.

    There are also emerging reports which say four Italian soldiers were injured after two rockets hit a UNIFIL base in Chamaa. Italy’s deputy prime minister has said Hezbollah was likely behind the rocket firing: “There were believed to be two missiles, from what it appears, they are believed to have been launched by Hezbollah.”

    Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni issued a statement of “deep indignation and concern” over “new attacks suffered by the Italian headquarters of UNIFIL in southern Lebanon.”

    “These attacks are unacceptable,” she stated, adding that “the parties on the ground to guarantee, at all times, the safety of UNIFIL soldiers and to collaborate to quickly identify those responsible.”

    “We are aware of heavy shelling in the vicinity of our bases,” UNIFIL spokesman Andrea Tenenti has said, saying that since the incident all UN troops appear to be safe “for the moment”.

    Up until now, the UNIFIL has claimed its command posts came under attack by Israeli forces, including IDF tanks, several times. This appears to be the first time that Hezbollah fired on UN locations.

    IDF forces earlier this week reached their deepest point into Lebanon since the ground invasion began, in the countryside vicinity of the port city of Tyre, which has been pummeled by airstrikes.

    UNIFIL base (in the background) in Chamaa, Lebanon. Wiki Commons

    Israel has repeatedly demanded that the UNIFIL troops withdraw – requests which have been refused. This puts the UNIFIL outposts in the direct line of fire as the war encircles their positions.

    “UNIFIL strongly urges combating parties to avoid fighting next to its positions. Inviolability of UN premises and personnel must be respected at all times,” a Friday statement said.

    Tyler Durden
    Fri, 11/22/2024 – 18:00

    Ukraine seeking new air-defence systems after latest Russian strike: Zelensky

    Ukraine is asking its Western partners for updated air defence systems after Russia fired an ultra-fast ballistic missile at the city of Dnipro this week, President Volodymyr Zelensky said Friday. “Ukraine’s defence minister is already holding meetings with our partners on new air defence systems — exactly the kind of systems that can protect lives […]

    The post Ukraine seeking new air-defence systems after latest Russian strike: Zelensky appeared first on Insider Paper.

    You Missed

    What Ceasefire? ‘Heavy Clashes’ In South Lebanon As Beirut Buildings Leveled

    What Ceasefire? ‘Heavy Clashes’ In South Lebanon As Beirut Buildings Leveled

    Ukraine seeking new air-defence systems after latest Russian strike: Zelensky

    Ukraine seeking new air-defence systems after latest Russian strike: Zelensky

    Trump Taps Pam Bondi for Attorney General Role After Matt Gaetz Withdraws

    Trump Taps Pam Bondi for Attorney General Role After Matt Gaetz Withdraws

    Utility Companies Are Not On Our Side

    Utility Companies Are Not On Our Side

    Yes Alexandria, No Means NO!

    Yes Alexandria, No Means NO!

    Russia says it needs migrants to fill labour shortage

    Russia says it needs migrants to fill labour shortage