New York Fed Report: 27 Percent of Bank Capital Is “Extend and Pretend” Commercial Real Estate Loans


by Pam Martens and Russ Martens, Wall St On Parade:

 

The New York Fed, long the quintessential keeper of secrets for the Wall Street megabanks that it has been bailing out since the financial crisis of 2008, has suddenly decided to come clean on a big threat to capital at these and other banks.

The New York Fed has created gasps in the corridors of power in the banking world by releasing a paper that documents how banks have ginned up their capital by “extending and pretending” on their underwater commercial real estate (CRE) loans.

The new paper was written by Matteo Crosignani, Financial Research Advisor at the New York Fed, and Saketh Prazad, a former Research Analyst at the New York Fed who is now a Doctoral Student in the Business Economics program at the Harvard Business School.

TRUTH LIVES on at https://sgtreport.tv/

The authors get right to the crux of the matter on page two of the report, writing this:

“In this paper, using detailed supervisory data, we document that banks have ‘extended-and-pretended’ their distressed CRE mortgages in the post-pandemic period to delay the recognition of losses. Banks with weaker marked-to-market capital—largely due to losses in their securities portfolio since 2022:Q1—have extended the maturity of their impaired CRE mortgages coming due and pretended that such credit provision was not as distressed to avoid further depleting their capital. The resulting limited number of loan defaults hindered the reallocation of capital, crowding out the origination of both CRE mortgages and loans to firms. The maturity extensions granted by banks also fueled the volume of CRE mortgages set to mature in the near term—a ‘maturity wall’ with the associated risk of large losses materializing in a short period of time.”

One of the scariest potential outcomes referenced by the authors is their so-called “maturity wall” when the debt bombs come due and losses pile up suddenly. The authors write this:

“…we document that banks’ extend-and-pretend has led to an ever-expanding ‘maturity wall’, namely a rapidly increasing volume of CRE loans set to mature in the near term. As of 2023:Q4, CRE mortgages coming due within three years represent 27% of bank marked-to-market capital, up 11 percentage points from 2020:Q4—and CRE mortgages coming due within five years represent 40% of bank marked-to-market capital. We show (i) that weakly capitalized banks drive this expansion, consistent with their extend-and-pretend behavior, and (ii) that the maturity wall represents a sizable 16% of the aggregate CRE debt held by the banking sector as of 2023:Q4.

“Taken together, our results highlight the costs of banks’ extend-and-pretend behavior. In the short term, the resulting credit misallocation might slow down the capital reallocation needed to sustain the transition of real estate markets to the post-pandemic equilibrium—for example supporting the conversion of office space into residential units and recreational spaces in large urban areas. In the medium term, the delayed recognition of losses exposes banks (and all other holders of CRE debt) to sudden large losses which can be exacerbated by fire sales dynamics and bankruptcy courts congestion.”

The authors refer to this extend-and-pretend behavior as another “manifestation of zombie lending, namely the provision of subsidized credit to impaired borrowers.”

The phrase, “zombie lending” reminded us of a scene from the movie, The Big Short, based on the Michael Lewis book by the same name on the 2008 financial collapse. This is the scene where actor Steve Carell, playing the character Mark Baum, is sitting in the audience at the American Securitization Forum and interrupts the speaker on stage who has just stated that he expects subprime losses “will be contained at 5 percent.” Baum stands up and boisterously asks: “Would you say that it is a possibility or a probability that subprime losses stop at 5 percent?” The speaker says: “I would say that it is a very strong probability, indeed.” Baum sits back down in his seat in the audience but then begins to waive his arm in the air, forming a zero with his fingers. Baum then shouts out: “Zero! Zero! There is a zero percent chance that your subprime losses will stop at 5 percent.” (You can watch the scene in the video below.)

The character in the movie, Mark Baum, was based on a real Wall Street person, Steve Eisman. For the hubris of that story involving the Fed, see our report: Steve Eisman and FrontPoint Were Shorting Wall Street Banks While the Dumb Fed Was Giving FrontPoint Emergency Loans – and that’s not the Worst Part of this Story.

The authors of this extend-and-pretend study, Crosignani and Prazad, are effectively doing what the Baum character in that scene from The Big Short did. They are yelling out in a public forum that this banking era of extend-and-pretend is unlikely to end well.

Read More @ WallStOnParade.com


Originally Posted at https://www.sgtreport.com


  • Related Posts

    Former NATO Spokesperson Says Europe May Need To Spend 5% Of GDP On Defense

    Former NATO Spokesperson Says Europe May Need To Spend 5% Of GDP On Defense

    A former NATO spokesperson has said members of the 32-nation bloc may need to spend 4 or 5 percent of their GDP on defense in the coming years, especially if the United States pulls back on its commitments under President-elect Donald Trump.

    The Epoch Times’ Chris Summers reports that Oana Lungescu, who worked at NATO between 2010 and 2024, told a Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) briefing in London on Thursday, that a majority of America’s allies in NATO were spending at least 2 percent of GDP on defense.

    But she said, “Obviously, we’re in a better place than we used to be, but is 2 percent enough? Does anybody here think that 2 percent is enough?”

    She was speaking as the Ukrainian military claimed Russian forces struck the Ukrainian city of Dnipro with an intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) on Nov. 21.

    The alleged ICBM strike happened just days after reports emerged the United States had allowed Ukraine to use U.S.-origin long-range weapons for deep strikes inside Russian territory; a request Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has made for months.

    Russia says Ukraine used the Army Tactical Missile Systems (ATACMS) against Russia’s Bryansk region on Nov. 19.

    Amid the apparent escalation of the Ukrainian conflict, Lungescu, said: “I would think that there will be a big push towards 3 percent and frankly, we should not need Donald Trump to tell us that we need [to spend] 3 percent.

    “Frankly, if there is any change or moderation of the US commitment to Europe … we will need 4 percent and 5 percent of GDP on defense.”

    Lungescu said: “Interestingly, there’s a new poll in Germany just the other day showing that 50 percent of those asked said that 3 to 3.5 percent is about right, which is a huge, huge mindset change for Germany.”

    In February, Trump told journalists in New York that “NATO countries have to pay up.”

    “The United States is in for $2oo billion and they’re in for $25 billion,” he said. “They’re not paying what they should, and they laugh at the stupidity of the United States of America.”

    Thursday’s briefing, hosted by the British defense think tank RUSI, was headlined “The impact of the U.S. presidential election on European security.”

    Jim Townsend, a former U.S. deputy assistant secretary of defense for European and NATO policy under President Barack Obama, said the world situation was very different from when Trump left office in 2020, partly because of the growing relationship between Russia and China.

    Putin Expressing ‘Displeasure’

    He said, “There’s a lot of things that Putin is doing right now to express his displeasure over ATACMS sure, but also to message to the incoming administration, ‘don’t think that we’re close friends with you guys and you’re going to roll over us, Trump.’”

    Townsend said Russia was angry with the United States and he described the Kremlin’s reaction as: “We’re not happy with the West. We’re not happy with what you’re doing, and you’re going to see our fists about this.”

    Max Bergmann, director of the Europe, Russia, and Eurasia program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), described the relationship between Trump and Putin as a “bromance.”

    He predicted Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) would be Trump’s choice for secretary of state, and he pointed out Rubio had voted against President Joe Biden’s $95 billion funding package for Ukraine in February.

    Bergmann said the nominations Trump has so far made for his Cabinet suggested that in his second term, “the dial is turned up.”

    “It is time to … take Trump very seriously about what he has indicated that he wants to do,” he said.

    He added there had been lots of discussions about China’s leader Xi Jinping’s intentions with Taiwan, and “there was a common refrain, ‘You should read what he says and take them literally.’ And I think that’s true with Trump.”

    Bergmann said the president-elect wants to fundamentally change U.S. policy on European security, on Ukraine, and Russia.

    “I think when it comes to NATO that means basically a major paradigm shift.”

    NATO spokesperson Oana Lungescu (L) and NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg arrive for the NATO summit at the Ifema congress centre in Madrid on June 29, 2022. Javier Soriano/AFP via Getty Images

    Lungescu, a Romanian former journalist, predicted: “The next four years will be turbulent, will be complicated, and there may be many things that we don’t like.

    “But ultimately, if you look at the growing alignment between Russia, China, North Korea, Iran, these authoritarian states, which are all adversaries to what the U.S. stands for, and to what Europeans stand for.

    “It’s in our interests to stay calm, to plan, and to invest in what unites us, rather than in what divides us,” she added.

    Rutte Is ‘Friend of Trump’

    Lungescu said the new NATO secretary general, former Dutch prime minister Mark Rutte, had a “good working relationship with Donald Trump” and described himself as a friend of Trump.

    She said, “So I would expect Mark Rutte to try to go to Washington as quickly as possible to meet not just the new administration, but also the new Congress.”

    She said bipartisan support for NATO will be part of the calculus in terms of how the administration proceeds.

    “He will need to make the case … of why NATO is a good deal for the United States,” added Lungescu, who is now a senior fellow at RUSI.

    Lungescu said she thought the NATO summit in The Hague in June would be shorter than originally planned.

    She said Trump’s nomination of Matt Whitaker as the next U.S. permanent representative to NATO was “interesting” and “could be a positive sign.”

    Tyler Durden
    Sat, 11/23/2024 – 07:35

    Eric Hovde’s Wisconsin Senate Race Opens the Door to a Criminal Investigation

    by Jerome R. Corsi, American Thinker: The Democrats may have made a significant mistake in their all-too-obvious attempt to steal a U.S. Senate seat from GOP candidate Eric Hovde. As Hovde explained in a November 12 video, in the early hours of November 6, 2024, he received congratulatory calls for his apparent win. Then, suddenly, by 4:00 […]

    You Missed

    Former NATO Spokesperson Says Europe May Need To Spend 5% Of GDP On Defense

    Former NATO Spokesperson Says Europe May Need To Spend 5% Of GDP On Defense

    Eric Hovde’s Wisconsin Senate Race Opens the Door to a Criminal Investigation

    Eric Hovde’s Wisconsin Senate Race Opens the Door to a Criminal Investigation

    Telling Today’s Modern Women What They Need To Hear, NOT What They Want To Hear

    Telling Today’s Modern Women What They Need To Hear, NOT What They Want To Hear

    Lorn Must Watch Acolyte PART TWO: Charity Livestream for Children Hospitalized During Holidays

    • By WDWPro
    • November 23, 2024
    • 2 views
    Lorn Must Watch Acolyte PART TWO: Charity Livestream for Children Hospitalized During Holidays

    Christmas Fun at Universal Orlando! Disney & Gatorland Theme Park News | Resort Recon LIVEstream

    Christmas Fun at Universal Orlando! Disney & Gatorland Theme Park News | Resort Recon LIVEstream

    PLANES, TRAINS and AUTOMOBILES (1987) Full Movie & Commentary | The LRC Watch Party | Thanksgiving

    PLANES, TRAINS and AUTOMOBILES (1987) Full Movie & Commentary | The LRC Watch Party | Thanksgiving